• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Penso's Pizza: Discover the Best Pizza in New Philadelphia, OH

At Penso's Pizza, we celebrate the art of pizza-making, blending quality ingredients with a passion for flavor. Nestled in New Philadelphia, Ohio, our menu caters to all tastes, whether you crave our classic cheese pizza or prefer to personalize your own creation. Beyond pizza, indulge in savory calzones and hearty sandwiches, ensuring a delightful experience for everyone. With options for takeout, delivery, and outdoor seating, we prioritize customer convenience and comfort. Our dedicated staff is eager to elevate your dining experience, making Penso's Pizza a cherished spot for families and friends alike. Come savor the best pizza in town!

Penso's Pizza at a glance

  • Address 923 E High Ave, New Philadelphia, OH 44663
  • Phone (330) 343-0506
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Penso's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

joseph dan
5

Very yummy pizza!!! Usually order way to much but it differently doesn't go to waste by any means. Decent prices for what you get and decent service could not ask for much more

Kelly Lehigh
5

Best. Pizza in Phila!!! Tonight we got the thin crust for the first time and it was killer! The toppings were perfect, and the sauce ratio was on point! So many people skimp out on the best part of the pizza Thanks for making a quality pizza, making it as if you were going to be eating it. People don't do that anymore. Thanks for a great experience. You guys are the best!

Carol Ruszin
5

We have been eating Penso's Pizza at least once a week for the past 45 years. Great crust, delicious sauce, lots of toppings to choose from. Their chef salads and spaghetti are wonderful. We call so often they don't even ask for our name anymore. They are on the second generation of pizza makers and the third generation is in the wings. The three brothers each have their own shop in different cities and each one has a little different taste from the others but all are delicious. My children, grandchildren, and now my great grandson have all cut teeth on Penso's Pizza crust. The family is so friendly and warm, it feels like home. You'll love it!!

Sherry Wharton
5

We absolutely CAN NOT get enough of Penso's pizza!!! Fortunately for us, we're within walking distance from the Dover location & we sure take advantage of that! If you like your pizza with thicker sliced pepperoni, LOTS of cheese & a perfect crust then you need to try Penso's too!! 5 stars +

Mike Weigand (Speedweigand)
5

I've been loving Penzo's Pizza ever since I've had teeth! Completely unique almost soft pretzel-like crust, all the delicious toppings you'd expect. Although the recipe is the same, each of the three locations has it's own character. I highly recommend trying this pizza, I have never come across another pie like this in all my travels.

Keith Gamble
5

Delicious pizza. The best around. Service is tip top as well.

mankey on yt
5

oh my gos! Where do I start first the service was AMAZING but you know what’s even better the SALAD it is delightful I’ve never had anything better if I had to choose one thing to eat for the the rest of my life it would be THAT SALAD there was this teenage boy named Zayden he was the best and nicest worker I’ve ever met service was a 5/5 his salad was a 5/5 I love this place will definitely be recommending to ALL my friends

Steve Johnson
5

Best Pizza I've ever tasted in all my years on this earth! Carly Simon's song "Nobody does it better" comes to mind! Been to dozens of states... tasted hundreds of pizzas... nobody comes close! Top rating...5 Stars!!!! Absolutely the best!

Location

  • Penso's Pizza
    Penso's Pizza
    923 E High Ave, New Philadelphia, OH 44663 Hotline: (330) 343-0506

Welcome to the delightful world of Penso's Pizza, a charming eatery nestled in New Philadelphia, Ohio. Known for its exceptional pizza, Penso's has quickly become a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike. With a prime location at 923 E High Ave and a commitment to quality, this unclaimed pizza destination is sure to entice your taste buds.

Penso's Pizza stands out not only for its menu but also for its array of amenities. Customers can enjoy takeout, delivery, and even outdoor seating for those sunny Ohio days. The establishment is wheelchair accessible, making it a welcoming space for everyone. Whether you're dining with family, friends, or a large group, Penso's is well-equipped to accommodate your needs. They also take reservations and accept credit cards, offering convenience along with their delicious offerings.

Now, let’s dive into what makes Penso's truly special. Their pizza is often heralded as one of the best in the area. With top-quality ingredients and a thick crust that balances flavors seamlessly, it’s no wonder patrons rave about their experiences. According to local reviewer D.P., Penso's serves "the best pizza we have had in the area," which speaks volumes about their commitment to excellence.

Beyond pizza, Penso's also offers a variety of tantalizing options including fresh salads, such as the Tossed Salad and the hearty Chef’s Salad, both priced affordably. Notably, their Calzone is another standout dish, promising a fulfilling experience while also catering to diverse palates. For those seeking a different flavor, the Fish Sandwich or the Meatball Sub with Cheese are must-tries as well.

While a few patrons have mentioned challenges with communication, the underlying sentiment remains clear: Penso's Pizza is a wonderful culinary destination. With a dedicated staff and a commitment to quality, this pizza place is poised to enhance your dining experience. As Michael C. aptly pointed out, it's a fantastic spot for take-out, making it a top choice for pizza aficionados.

In conclusion, whether you’re a pizza lover or just in search of a delicious meal, Penso's Pizza is well worth a visit. The next time you find yourself in New Philadelphia, don’t miss the opportunity to savor a slice (or two) from this fantastic establishment!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • Offers kerbside pickup
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards